Ikusasa Grain Mills Business Plan — Debt Service Coverage & Break-Even

Reconstructing the schedule from the stated terms confirms the Company's figures exactly. Interest-only service in Year 1 on R16.0 million at 11.5% is…

Debt Service Coverage & Break-Even

Jump to section

16.1 The senior facility

Figure 21. Senior debt: R16.0m at 11.5% with a 12-month capital moratorium.

Reconstructing the schedule from the stated terms confirms the Company’s figures exactly. Interest-only service in Year 1 on R16.0 million at 11.5% is R1.84 million, matching the stated Year-1 debt service to the rand. Full amortisation over eight years thereafter produces an annual service of R3.16 million, again matching. The debt structure is sound and the twelve-month moratorium is the correct accommodation for a plant that does not produce saleable output until month eleven.

Loan year

Opening balance

Interest

Principal

Debt service

Closing balance

Year 1

R16.00m

R1.84m

R0.00m

R1.84m

R16.00m

Year 2

R16.00m

R1.76m

R1.40m

R3.16m

R14.60m

Year 3

R14.60m

R1.59m

R1.57m

R3.16m

R13.03m

Year 5

R11.27m

R1.19m

R1.97m

R3.16m

R9.30m

Year 8

R4.61m

R0.38m

R2.78m

R3.16m

R1.83m

16.2 Coverage on three bases

Figure 22. Debt-service cover on three bases.

Basis

Year 1

Year 2

Year 3

Year 4

Year 5

As stated (EBITDA ÷ debt service)

1.31x

1.34x

1.94x

2.04x

2.15x

CFADS after tax and maintenance capex

1.31x

1.22x

1.66x

1.72x

1.79x

CFADS with assessed losses applied

1.31x

1.22x

1.79x

1.76x

1.79x

Key findingThe claim that coverage clears 1.25x in every year holds on EBITDA but not on a cash basis

The Plan states that coverage clears the 1.25 times covenant in every year of the projection, with the tightest point in Year 2. Both halves of that statement are correct on an EBITDA basis, Year 2 is 1.34 times, the lowest of the five years. On a cash basis, however, after a modest R0.35 million allowance for maintenance capital expenditure beyond the R1.7 million of maintenance and consumables already carried in conversion costs, Year-2 cover is approximately 1.22 times: marginally below the covenant. Applying the assessed losses correctly does not help in Year 2, because the Company is still loss-making then; the benefit arrives in Year 3, lifting cover from 1.66 to 1.79 times. The Plan should present coverage on a cash basis and identify Year 2 explicitly as the covenant-testing year, because that is how an agro-processing lender will model it.

Analyst flagOne point of gross margin is the difference between comfort and breach

Because the entire projection rests on a constant 11.3% gross margin, the sensitivity of coverage to that assumption is the number that matters most. A single percentage point of margin compression costs R0.79 million of EBITDA in Year 2 and R0.98 million in Year 3. In Year 2 that takes coverage from 1.34 times to approximately 1.09 times, a clear breach. In an oversupplied segment which the Plan itself describes as having pressured profitability, one point of margin is not a remote scenario. This is the single most important stress a credit committee should run, and the Company should run it first.

16.3 Break-even including debt service

Figure 23. Break-even throughput including debt service.

Measure

Year 1

Year 2

Year 3

Year 4

Year 5

Maize milled (tonnes)

8640

12240

14400

14400

14400

Break-even including debt service (tonnes)

7816

10791

10556

10343

10151

Break-even as % of planned throughput

90.5%

88.2%

73.3%

71.8%

70.5%

Break-even as % of installed capacity

54.3%

74.9%

73.3%

71.8%

70.5%

Covering overheads and debt service requires approximately 7,816 tonnes in Year 1 against 8,640 planned, 90.5% of the ramp target, though only 54% of installed capacity because the moratorium limits Year-1 service to interest. Year 2 is the binding year: break-even of 10,791 tonnes represents 88% of the planned 12,240 tonnes and 75% of installed capacity, against an assumed 85% utilisation. From Year 3 the position eases materially, with break-even at roughly 73% of throughput and falling to 70% by Year 5.